Sears Auto Center Scandal - 1475 Words

LGST001 Ââ€" Ethics and Social Responsibility Sears Auto Center Scandal Managing Business Ethics Text (pp.207 - 210) Ethical Decision-making Issue: Should Sears remove its commission-based compensation scheme? Group Stand: The majority of the group believes that Ellen should be removed from the team. Support for Motion: Rawls theory/Egalitarianism The underlying inequality is that car owners are paying for repair services they do not require while Sears benefits by earning higher profits. This is a result of information asymmetry given that the repair advisors are in a more knowledgeable position regarding the available and required services, and clients act upon their advice. Thus, there is an opportunity for advisors†¦show more content†¦Objection against inequality There is no inequality in the case because customers have the rights to refuse any recommended services by the Sears mechanics. Being the paying parties, they are in the position to demand for specific services and not accept any other types of repairs and checks. Even if inequality exists, the inequality is fair since there is no information asymmetry which can render it otherwise. Consumers can always increase their understanding of their cars by researching, seeking advice from other auto repair companies, or learning from peers. Furthermore, the inequality is just if it increases utility in society. Using Utilitarianism theory for Distributive Justice, the compensation plan maximizes profits which in turn affects the economy positively. With the additional profits, Sears is hence able to expand and hire more employees, and this will benefit shareholders in terms of dividend growth and increase share prices. More workers will be employed. This benefits economy and society altogeth er, thus the inequality is just. Ethical Egoism Following the argument for ethical egoism, everyone will do what is to their best interest first. Ultimately, this will achieve utilitarianism since problems regarding wastage and inefficiency will be tackled. The compensation scheme supports ethical egoism and society will be able to benefit as aShow MoreRelatedSears, Roebuck, and Co. the Auto Center Scandal2644 Words   |  11 PagesSEARS, ROEBUCK, AND CO. THE AUTO CENTER SCANDAL History and Introduction of Sear, Roebuck, and Co. Sears, Roebuck and Co began in the 19th century and sold farm supplies and consumer items as a small mail order company. The first Sears retail store opened up in Chicago on the 2nd February 1925 in the building named the Merchandise. This store had included a soda fountain and an optical shop. The first detached and separate retail store opened up on the 5th October 1925 in a city called EvansvilleRead MoreAnalysis of Sears, Roebuck Co, the Auto Center Scandal1367 Words   |  6 PagesStudy Sears, Roebuck Co, the Auto Center Scandal Ethical Issues 1. The first issue that presents itself is the aggressive, Profit seeking approach been taken by Sears in their implementation of an extremely tight incentive system within their Auto centers to increase productivity and reduce cost. 2. Sears was acting very unethical as they disregarded stake holders such as employees, customers and partners in their efforts to reel in profits. 3. Sear president andRead MoreBusiness Analysis: Sears, Roebuck, and Co. Essay1052 Words   |  5 PagesSears, Roebuck, and Co. seemed to have the right idea when beginning their business in the late 1800s. Instead of just opening up one type of company, Sears, Roebuck, and Co. expanded from retail to insurance, real estate, securities, and credit cards (Nelson, 2007, p. 207). Until the early 1990s, the company seemed to be doing very well considering the revenue and earnings reported that equaled up to billions of dollars. Then, the company began to experience financial difficulties due to the factRead MoreOrganizational Ethics934 Words   |  4 Pagesfollowing case studies from Managing Business Ethics as assigned by your facilitator. The case studies are found in the text near the end of the given chapter. o Merck and River Blindness in Ch. 2 o Pinto Fires in Ch. 4 o Sears, Roebuck, and Co.: The Auto Center Scandal in Ch. 7 o Videotek Corporation in Ch. 9 o Culture Change at Texaco in Ch. 9 o An Unethical Culture in Need of Change: Tap Pharmaceuticals in Ch. 9 6. Learning Team Assignment: Current Ethical Issue in Business Paper Read MoreMotivation by Commission Based Pay4502 Words   |  19 Pagessued or face regulatory sanctions incuuding loss of business licence ( Inderst Ottaviani, 2009). Fraud accucatsion over auto repair sales staff on commissions cost Sears $15 million in refunds and other legal costs. Sear’s auto repairs were accused of padding their commissions by falsesly diagnosing brake and alignment problems. As a result after the errupted scandal, Sears has stopped paying commissions and elimated the job of the service adviser. Their new compensation plan is now based 60% baseRead MoreMarketing Mistakes and Successes175322 Words   |  702 Pagesotherwise, except as permitted under Sections 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, website www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030-5774, (201)748-6011Read MoreInternational Management67196 Words   |  269 Pagessimulations on the Online Learning Center complete the package. To help instructors teach international management, this text is accompanied by a revised and expanded Instructor’s Resource Manual, Test Bank, and PowerPoint Slides, all of which are available password protected on the Online Learning Center at www.mhhe. com/luthans8e. Two other innovations new to the eighth edition are an additional case, Nokia Targets the Base of the Pyramid, available on the Online Learning Center (www.mhhe. com/luthans8e)Read MoreTeaching Notes Robert Grant - Strategy 4th Edition51665 Words   |  207 Pagestheir impact on competition and proï ¬ tability. Analyzing market segments. Key success factors. Reading: Case: Grant, Chaps. 3 and 4 DaimlerChrysler and the World Automobile Industry Discussion questions: 1. What changes in the structure of the world auto industry between 1970 and 2001 caused industry proï ¬ tability to decline? 2. How is the industry likely to evolve over the next ten years and will it be more or less proï ¬ table than the past ï ¬ ve years? 3. Which companies will be most successful over theRead MoreManagement and Rolls Access Code14663 Words   |  59 Pagespeople and materials to do it, lead and direct the workers, and impose some controls to ensure that everything was done as planned. Another example of early management can be seen during the 1400s in the city of Venice, a major economic and trade center. The Venetians developed an early form of business enterprise and engaged in many activities common to today’s organizations. For instance, at the arsenal of Venice, warships were floated along the canals and at each stop, materials and riggings wereRead MoreAn Assessment of the Impact of Corporate Social Responsibility on Nige rian Society: the Examples of Banking and Communication Industries18990 Words   |  76 Pageslibrary. Julius Rosenwald fathered the country farm agent system and adopted the infant 4-H CLUBS. Carnegie was already retired from business and one of the world’s richest men. Rosenwald who had recently bought a near bankrupt mail order firm called Sear Roebuck and Company, was only beginning to build both his business and fortune. The two held basically different philosophies. Carnegie believed that the sole purpose of being rich is to be a philanthropist, that is, the â€Å"social responsibility of wealth†